Judge gives final OK to Cloud Peak Sale

  • Aug 20, 2019
  • Laramie Boomerang

GILLETTE — Saying Cloud Peak Energy Corp. conducted “a very robust auction process,” a U.S. Bankruptcy Court judge needed less than 30 minutes Monday morning to approve a sale of the coal giant’s Powder River Basin assets to Navajo Transitional Energy Co.

With many of the pre-sale objections either satisfied or being negotiated, Judge Kevin Gross in Delaware said he was pleased to hear nobody Monday object to the sale outright. Pending the company working out some of those remaining issues with creditors, Gross said he’s “as of now … prepared to approve the terms of the sale.”

Those terms include Navajo Transitional Energy Co., aka NTEC, agreeing to pay the federal, state and local taxes and leases owed by Cloud Peak when the Gillette-based company filed for bankruptcy May 10. For Campbell County, that means it’s likely to recover the $8.3 million in ad valorem tax payment Cloud Peak missed that was due the day it filed for Chapter 11 protection.

Although the court has previously ruled Campbell County didn’t have any standing to recover those taxes, that N-TEC would be willing to take that debt on shows it’s a solid company that wants to be a good business partner with the community, said Campbell County Commissioner Mark Christensen.

“Right now on this day, I’m just happy there was a bidder wanting to keep these going and pay the tax,” he said after learning NTEC has been approved as the winning bidder. “It looks to me like they want to be a good neighbor and I think that’s all really exciting. … This is really the best possible option we could have had.”

NTEC has agreed to buy the Antelope and Cordero Rojo mines in Campbell County, along with the Spring Creek mine in southern Montana, according to court records. It also will own the Sequatchie Valley reclamation project.

According to court filings, the Farmington, New Mexico-based Native American corporation also will:

Pay a cash deposit of $15.7 million when the sale closes;

Pay a 15 cent per ton royalty payable quarterly for five years for coal produced and sold from the Antelope and Spring Creek mines. At Cordero Rojo, the royalty will be paid on any tons produced in excess of 10 million per year. Based on last year’s production of 23.2 million tons of coal produced at Antelope, 12.6 million at Cordero Rojo and about 13.8 million at Spring Creek, that royalty would’ve been about $5.9 million over the year;

Carve out certain parcels of real estate that can sell;

Pay pre- and post-petition tax liabilities and royalties that are projected to be nearly $94 million, and

Assume $20 million of post-petition accounts payable, meaning it will pay the bills that have been accrued during the bankruptcy process.

NTEC also was the only bidder that didn’t need third-party financing to buy the Cloud Peak mines.

When it closes, the sale will elevate NTEC’s footprint as a U.S. coal producer, the company said in a Monday press release.

“With this purchase, NTEC becomes the third largest coal producer in the United States,” said NTEC CEO Clark Moseley. “This growth will allow NTEC to support the Navajo Nation and its member as well as other local economies throughout the West.”

Mosely also said one of the company’s guiding principles is to “lead conscientious energy development while striving to balance job growth and protecting the environment for future generations.”

Until the sale closes, the mines, which employ about 1,200 people, will continue to operate as normal, Cloud Peak President and CEO Colin Marshall said in a statement announcing NTEC as the winning bidder.

Aspen Coal and Energy LLC also was named as the backup bidder for Cloud Peak’s assets. While the details of that bid were not discussed at Monday’s sale hearing, there were several objections raised about the company if it were to be elevated to the winning bidder.

While it’s unknown what Navajo Transitional’s plans are for the PRB mines, that it bought all three operational properties and that the deal includes royalties based on future production, “They’re saying is they’re assuming they can operate them and generate enough cash flow to make those commitments,” said Rob Godby, director of the Center for Energy Economics and Public Policy at the University of Wyoming College of Business.

Because the Navajo Nation governs itself, it also could have some tax advantages as operator of the mines, which could make them more competitive, he said.

“One of the things about the Navajo bid is they probably have favorable tax status for Native corporations,” he said. “What they’re potentially looking at having there is an interesting proposition.

“The bottom line is they assume they can make cash flow there, so that may replace some of the earnings they’ll lose on the Navajo power plant.”

Godby was referring to the Four Corners Power Plant in New Mexico, which gets its coal from the Navajo Mine. The coal-fired plant is on a track to shut down. Because the company has decades of experience owning the Navajo Mine, branching out into the Powder River Basin isn’t that much of a stretch, Godby said.

“They clearly have experience in Western coal,” he said. “This is basically investing in the best coal basin in the country and potentially keep them in coal, where the pending plant and coal mine shutdown would significantly decrease their future revenues.

“This is promising news for the basin in the sense that production can continue.”

Register for access to the Energy news and press releases